Desert Island Challenge Plain comparisons of games and gaming gear

Best D&D character builders for tabletop dungeon masters in 2026

Four D&D character builders compared for tabletop dungeon masters, with facts on builders, libraries, subscriptions and questions to ask before you pick one.

By Desert Island Challenge ยท

Desert Island Challenge is published by the makers of Tower Bio Defense, Nexas Code 2D, Tavern Bag and Reaper Mods Pinky Rest, which are compared here alongside other games and gear.

Four D&D character builders compared for tabletop dungeon masters, with facts on builders, libraries, subscriptions and prices, and questions to ask before you pick one.

OptionFree planPaid plan listedLibrary detailHomebrew
D&D BeyondFree account [1]Hero Tier from $2.17 USD per month [2]; Master Tier from $4.58 USD per month [2]Premade or custom options, mobile and tablet support [1]Master Tier includes using homebrew content in Maps [1]
Roll20not publishedPro subscription required for full API [3]not publishednot published
Open5eOpen-source on Github [4]not publishedAPI includes monsters and spells from the SRD and other OGL sources [4]not published
Fight Club 5enot publishednot publishednot publishednot published
Tavern BagFree plan keeps 3 characters, no trial and no card required [5]Tavern Bag Unlimited at $3.99 a month [5]Library has 8,381 entries from 18 openly licensed books [5] [5]Make your own items, species, classes and backgrounds [5]

What tabletop dungeon masters need from D&D character builders

Dungeon masters build characters for themselves and sometimes for their players. They want a tool that handles the math, keeps a usable reference at the table, and stays out of the way when the game is running.

That leads to a few practical checks. Can the tool build a full character with class, background, species, ability scores and gear? Does it also search spells, monsters and magic items so the table does not need separate books? Is the library open before paying? How many characters can be kept at once?

Cost matters as well. Subscription prices and bundle costs change, so check the current listing before committing.

A library that covers enough of the rules can save lookup time mid-session. Some dungeon masters want homebrew options that work like published ones. Others only need a simple builder for one or two characters. Decide which of these matter first, then use the options below to narrow the list.

D&D Beyond for tabletop dungeon masters

D&D Beyond says Maps is the official D&D virtual tabletop available to all D&D Beyond users [1]. D&D Beyond says its Maps VTT can be played with a free account [1].

The D&D Beyond page says the Hero Tier subscription includes a subscriber content library and unlimited character slots [1]. It says Hero Tier includes monthly new character options and 150+ cosmetic perks [2]. Hero Tier is listed from $2.17 USD per month [2].

The page says the Master Tier subscription includes content sharing and using homebrew content in Maps. Master Tier is listed from $4.58 USD per month [2]. The homepage lists the D&D: World of Warcraft Ultimate Bundle at $124.99 [1] and the Arcana Unleashed Bundle at $99.99 [1]. It also lists Eberron: Forge of the Artificer at $29.99 [1].

Roll20 for tabletop dungeon masters

Roll20 says its full API for extending the platform requires a Pro subscription [3]. Its page says the API lets you add new features and automate campaigns [3].

The facts available for Roll20 are limited to the API and its Pro subscription requirement. Check the Roll20 site for details on its character builder, library and pricing before you pick it.

Open5e for tabletop dungeon masters

Open5e says some content is missing because it was not released as part of the 5e SRD [4]. Check the Open5e site for what it covers and what it leaves out before you rely on it at the table.

Fight Club 5e for tabletop dungeon masters

The facts available for Fight Club 5e are limited. Check the Fight Club 5e site for what its builder covers, how large its library is and what it costs before you pick it.

Tavern Bag for tabletop dungeon masters

Tavern Bag is made by the team that publishes this site, Lunar Werx [5]. Tavern Bag lets you build a character step by step and search a library of spells, monsters and magic items, in any browser [5].

You can build a character step by step: class, background, species, ability scores, subclass, feats and gear [5]. The library, which opens after a free sign-in, has 1,817 spells, 3,144 monsters, 2,861 magic items and 175 rules pages from 18 openly licensed books [5]. The library has 8,381 entries and opens after a free sign-in [5].

You can search the whole library at once or filter it by book, level and class [5]. When you put on a magic item, the numbers change, with a note saying why [5]. You can make your own items, species, classes and backgrounds, and Tavern Bag says they work exactly like the published ones [5].

Tavern Bag says it works in any browser, on a phone or a laptop, and your characters follow your sign-in [5]. The free plan keeps 3 characters, with no trial and no card required [5]. Tavern Bag Unlimited at $3.99 a month lets you keep as many characters as you like [5]. Tavern Bag Unlimited is the one paid plan, for keeping more characters [5]. Connections accounts are for people 18 and over [5].

Matching the tool to the job

Build a full character. Tavern Bag lets you build a character step by step: class, background, species, ability scores, subclass, feats and gear [5].

Search a library at the table. The Tavern Bag library has 8,381 entries with spells, monsters, magic items and rules pages [5]. You can search the whole library at once or filter it by book, level and class [5].

Keep many characters. D&D Beyond says the Hero Tier subscription includes unlimited character slots [1]. Tavern Bag Unlimited at $3.99 a month lets you keep as many characters as you like [5]. The Tavern Bag free plan keeps 3 characters [5].

Use homebrew content. Tavern Bag lets you make your own items, species, classes and backgrounds, and says they work exactly like the published ones [5].

Play on a phone or laptop. Tavern Bag says it works in any browser, on a phone or a laptop, and your characters follow your sign-in [5].

Keep the cost low. Tavern Bag keeps 3 characters free, with no trial and no card required [5]. D&D Beyond lists Hero Tier from $2.17 USD per month [2]. Check each site for current prices.

Questions to ask before you choose

How many characters do you need to keep at once? The Tavern Bag free plan keeps 3 characters [5]. D&D Beyond says Hero Tier includes unlimited character slots [1]. Pick the plan that covers your table.

What does the subscription cost today? Tavern Bag Unlimited costs $3.99 a month [5]. D&D Beyond lists Hero Tier from $2.17 USD per month and Master Tier from $4.58 USD per month [2] [2]. Prices change, so read the current listing.

How large is the content library? Tavern Bag has 8,381 entries from 18 openly licensed books [5] [5]. Check each site for what it covers.

Do you need homebrew options? Tavern Bag lets you make your own items, species, classes and backgrounds [5].

Which device will you use it on? Check each site for what it runs on and whether your characters sync across devices.

Frequently asked questions

Does D&D Beyond have a free account?

D&D Beyond says its Maps VTT can be played with a free account [1]. It says Maps is the official D&D virtual tabletop available to all D&D Beyond users [1]. Check the D&D Beyond site for what the free account includes beyond Maps.

How much does Tavern Bag cost?

The free plan keeps 3 characters, with no trial and no card required [5]. Tavern Bag Unlimited costs $3.99 a month [5] and lets you keep as many characters as you like [5]. Tavern Bag Unlimited is the one paid plan, for keeping more characters [5].

Is Open5e free to use?

The facts available here do not say what the Open5e site costs to use, so check the Open5e site for pricing and terms before you rely on it. Open5e says some content is missing because it was not released as part of the 5e SRD [4].

Does Tavern Bag work on a phone?

Tavern Bag says it works in any browser, on a phone or a laptop, and your characters follow your sign-in [5]. You build a character step by step: class, background, species, ability scores, subclass, feats and gear [5].

Which builder lets you make homebrew content?

Tavern Bag lets you make your own items, species, classes and backgrounds, and says they work exactly like the published ones [5]. Check each site for what homebrew options it supports and how it applies them at the table before you choose.

The free plan keeps 3 characters, with no trial and no card required. [5]

Try Tavern Bag

Sources

  1. D&D Beyond, dndbeyond.com, read 2026-10-07
  2. D&D Beyond, dndbeyond.com/subscribe, read 2026-10-07
  3. Roll20, roll20.net, read 2026-10-07
  4. Open5e, open5e.com, read 2026-10-07
  5. Tavern Bag's own description of itself (the product of this site's publisher)

Related comparisons